Brother John's Sub & Sandwich

Discover delicious sandwiches, pizza, salads, and more at Brother John's Sub & Sandwich Restaurant in Toccoa, GA. Enjoy great prices, tasty to-go options, and favorites like meatballs, turkey, steak sandwiches, reuben, and cookies. Call +1 706-886-9597 today!

Welcome to Brother John's Sub & Sandwich

Taste the Difference.

Brother John's Sub & Sandwich
Brother John's Sub & Sandwich
Brother John's Sub & Sandwich
Brother John's Sub & Sandwich

Brother John's Sub & Sandwich stands as a cherished spot in Toccoa, Georgia. Located at 27 Stephen Cir, this inviting restaurant specializes in hearty subs, satisfying salads, and delightful desserts. At this sandwich haven, the goal is simple: provide quality food at fair prices. Customers rave about the variety of subs, like the famed meatball and Reuben. The relaxing atmosphere complements the scrumptious menu, making it a perfect place for quick bites and family gatherings. Whether you're grabbing a meal to-go or enjoying a sit-down lunch, the friendly service ensures a welcoming experience every time.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

27 Stephen Cir, Toccoa, GA 30577, United States

Phone

+1 706-886-9597

About

The Culinary Story

Brother John's Sub & Sandwich
Brother John's Sub & Sandwich
Brother John's Sub & Sandwich
Brother John's Sub & Sandwich

Brother John's Sub & Sandwich is more than just a place to eat—it’s a local institution in Toccoa, Georgia. This beloved sandwich shop has built a reputation for its generous portions and scrumptious flavors since it opened its doors. The wide-ranging menu features various categories, including cold subs, hot subs, salads, and even kid's meals. Patrons often find themselves torn between a classic Turkey sub or the robust BBQ Beef. With 61 items on the menu, every visit offers something exciting to try, whether it's a 5-inch personal pizza for the little ones or Dippin' Dots for dessert.

The atmosphere radiates warmth, making it an ideal dining spot for both regulars and newcomers. The laid-back vibe invites conversations, laughter, and shared meals, often with familiar faces. Regulars appreciate the staff’s friendly service that makes them feel right at home. They welcome feedback and make an effort to enhance the menu continuously. To add a local flavor, you may catch some community event flyers posted on walls, showing the restaurant's commitment to supporting local happenings. The reasonable price points make Brother John's a go-to for everyone, whether you're in the mood for a quick lunch break or a hearty sit-down meal while catching up with friends.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • SundayClosed
  • Monday11 AM-3 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-6 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-6 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-6 PM
  • Friday11 AM-6 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-3 PM

Brother John's Sub & Sandwich boasts an extensive menu that caters to all tastes, featuring 61 delightful dishes. For those craving cold subs, a standout is the Big Ben, while hot sub lovers can't resist the Steak - All The Way. Variety extends beyond sandwiches, as salads and delicious desserts, like large chocolate chunk cookies and brownies, round out the offerings. The restaurant's commitment to affordability shines through with an overall average price of just $6.35. Plus, with kid's meals priced around $4.80, families find dining here enjoyable and budget-friendly. Conveniently situated in Toccoa, the restaurant's take-out option ensures that everyone can indulge in their favorite meals on the go, making weekday lunches or busy family dinners hassle-free.

Brother John's Sub & Sandwich

The exterior of Brother John's Sub & Sandwich is as inviting as the food inside. Bright signage draws attention, welcoming hungry customers. Ample parking makes arriving convenient for everyone, whether for dine-in or take-out. The outdoor vibe invites you to relax while waiting for your order, making it a popular spot for locals who enjoy the community feel. Friendly faces of fellow diners often brighten the atmosphere, fostering a sense of belonging among first-time visitors and regulars alike.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

I've been eating here since i was a little kid. It is still just as amazing as it was back then. The new owners have done a phenomenal job at keeping it the exact same quality. Love this place

J
Josh M.

My wife usually goes in to get our weekly Wednesday night spaghetti dinners. We occasionally want Meatball subs for supper, but by this time in the day they are usually out of either meatballs, or bread. If you have people wanting to buy your product, even though there's a once in a while risk of having some left over, why not please the masses and make yourself extra profit by adding enough bread and meatballs for 30 extra subs ? Expand or decrease this number after a few weeks and if customers know they'll get what they want they'll come back. My family would, as we have eaten here via take-out more since the new owners took over than I personally did the whole 30+ years when the previous folks owned BJS. Not being critical, just offering business advice to help Brother Johns thrive and grow, plus get me my Meatball Sub ! I also like their Italian Sub, or those delicious plates of spaghetti ! Lol. I'd love if they added a 100% lamb meat selection to their menu. Great products, great service, very clean !

B
Bucky S.

This was our first experience dining here, and it did not disappoint. The food was amazing, and the customer service was top-notch. We will absolutely be back!

K
Kellie H.

What a great restaurant! The employees are so kind, the service was quick and the food was delicious. If you are looking for somewhere to get a sub I would highly recommend Brother John's!

M
Michael R.

Awesome subs and daily specials.

M
Matt E.

We were in town and I was craving a sub, I did a google search and found this yummy place! The online ordering is well set up and easy to navigate but it was a little frustrating once I put in card info to order it said my time was no longer available and the next ordering time was the next day at 11:00, even though it was Thursday and they were open until 7 and I was ordering at 4. I was able to call and place a Togo order though and it was ready quickly. I got the Nancy Joe club , my husband got the chicken Philly and we got a hot dog kids meal for my son and a cookie. It was all delicious and reasonably priced. I got a small and was nervous it would be too small for me but it was really big, it was about half full sub ! We will definitely be back.

S
Sheridan A.